The “Proof” is in the Pie!
Looking for something unique for your wedding dessert? Try Sara’s Tipsy Pies! For dessert lovers who thrill to the unexpected and want to experience a new level of deliciousness. Sara’s Tipsy Pies go above and beyond with hand-crafted, high-quality pies that are infused with local wine, whiskey and craft beers.
We are offering eat in or carry out tastings to help keep people safe.
"Sara's Tipsy Pies provided the desserts for our wedding at Aria on Feb 12,2016. The assortment of pies, cupcakes, & cookies were absolutely delicious & were the hit of the night. Many of our guests said they tried each & every sweet treat....multiple times over. The display was beautiful as well! My husband & I were treated to our own personal goodie box at the end of the night...which we promptly dug into. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!!! We plan to take a trip back to Marine on St Croix to stock up on your wonderful treats soon. They hold the best memories for us!"
- Sarah & Peter
Book a Tipsy Pie tasting!
Meet with Sara for a private pie tasting were you'll taste up to 10 pies. Tastings are $50 and feed 4 people. You can find the fee under the store options. Come hungry!
"Sara was so helpful in helping us set up the dessert table AND the pies tasted amazing. All of our guests loved the pies and it truly could not have gone better. All of the pie flavors are fun and unique. Plus great customer service, so just a great combo. Highly recommend if you’re looking to mix things up from cake!"
- Jenna W.
"You cannot go wrong with Sara’s pies! They’re perfect if you and your guests are pie lovers. Also it’s nice that she’ll deliver and set up the dessert table too, it saves so much time on the day of! Also instead of splitting a mini pie with your groom-to- be, she’ll make you a heart shaped pie of your choice! They’re super cute!"
- Amanda P.
Tipsy Pie Extra Love!
We'll pack you a late night wedding treat box to take with you the night of your wedding! No more frost-bitten anniversary cake — we'll give you 4 fresh hand pies to celebrate on your first anniversary. Just contact us when you're ready!
"Thank you Sara Higgins-Hayden for helping make my sister's wedding extra special. Your fresh strawberry pies were amazing and clearly a labor of love. Your attention to detail, including going to over 10 farmers' markets to find the perfect locally-grown strawberries demonstrates how special and unique you and your budding enterprise are. I heard many guests, including my 3 daughters, comment that they now want pies for their future weddings!"
- Renee Thompson Arnold and Maria Arnold at Schultz Lake
Pies With a Purpose... Give More Than Love During Your Wedding
Now offering a more purposeful wedding. A percentage of your wedding pies made with Finnegans® will be donated to the "Pies With a Purpose" fund. Finnegans generously donates all the beer for this fundraising campaign!
"Loved working with Sara! LOVED the pies! Loved that a portion of the proceeds goes to a charitable organization which we already support. All our guests love the pies, cupcakes and cookies! Sara was easy to work with, responsive, on-time and provided delicious treats for our guests."
"Sara made Irish Apple, French Silk, and Lemon Meringue pies for our wedding in November of 2015. They were the highlight of our wedding! When we met with Sara for our tasting, we mentioned wanting lemon meringue. This wasn't a pie she typically made BUT Sara went above and beyond to make it for us. Sara delivered the pies and explained to the reception staff exactly how they should be set up. She did a fantastic job! The heart shaped hand pies and pie pals were BEAUTIFUL! If you are looking for something unique and equally delicious to serve at your wedding, look no further. Thank you for making our day so special, Sara!"
- Jillian Cole
"Wow! From our first meeting with Sara to taste pie, it was clear how passionate she is about her business and the quality of her product. Our wedding pies were a huge hit with our wedding guests, totally cleaned out (in fact, the only "complaint" I have is that I wish we had ordered more pies!). Sara made us a larger pie to cut, which was gorgeous. And the wooden stands to display our pies were a perfect match to the hand pies. We would recommend her tasty, tipsy pies to anyone looking for a creative take on wedding dessert"
- Cassie B.