Every one of our tipsy pies features my mom’s hand-rolled crust recipe with my special local alcohol twist on fillings (under 2% by volume, all ages can enjoy!). Visit us in Stillwater to find fresh baked or frozen pies waiting for you. Take them home and bake them yourself.

— Sara Hayden, Proud Owner

Looking for something unique for your wedding dessert? Try Sara’s Tipsy Pies! For dessert lovers who thrill to the unexpected and want to experience a new level of deliciousness. ​Sara’s Tipsy Pies go above and beyond with hand-crafted, high-quality pies that are infused with local wine, whiskey and craft beers. In an attempt to follow Covid-19 safety guidelines, all wedding tastings will be carry-out until further notice.

Our catering service covers a wide variety of events like corporate parties, holiday gift-giving, private, & theme parties. We work directly with you to bring you our handmade baked pies, tarts, and cookies. Tipsy pies will add that special touch to your next event or gift giving. Gluten-free options are available, because why should a gluten-free lifestyle keep you from enjoying our pies? Pickup and delivery options are available.

We are so excited Aug 2024!

WONDER what the new pie will be???

Stay tuned!